July 27, 2026 | Rome, Italy

Strangers and stories

Edith Nesbit, co-founder of the Fabian Society and writer of "The Railway Children," understood that sometimes strangers are friends.

Every night, when I tuck my daughter Julia into bed, she asks me to tell her a story. For a while, she would call out a number between one and my age, and ask for a story from when I was that age. Noting the abundance of stories from Italy — and the energy in my voice when telling them — nowadays, she just asks for “an Italy story.”

Although I’ve exhausted many of these stories, I always come up with something, even if it’s just a list of first foods I ate, or items of clothing, or first words in Italian. One story that I happened upon recently took place when I was nineteen, and traveling from Rome to Turin to visit my mother’s distant relatives in a little mountain village where I’d first been when I was nine.

I was just starting to learn Italian, which came easily having studied Spanish in high school. Still, I was straining to understand, and when the little train that had gone from Turin to the surrounding mountain villages slowed to a stop, I was stumped into silence. Surely the train would continue, I thought, staring at my little ticket destined for Frazione Braida, the village named for my ancestors.

But everyone was getting up to leave. After a few minutes, the train conductor came and said, Signorina, devi uscire. Miss, you have to leave.

Perplexed, I looked up at him. “Train stop-ud,” he said in broken English, making a sharp hand motion that I knew was Italian sign language for È finito. It’s over.

The dusky violet light hovered over unfamiliar mountains laced with vineyards. I was lost, but at least it was in a beautiful place. And, probably without hotels.

Panicked, I showed him my ticket. “No go,” he said, shaking his head and finger at the same time. “But I have to go to my relatives there,” I told him, about to cry. When he looked as confused as I was, I tried explaining in Italian —which worked enough for him to understand that I was stuck. The dusky violet light hovered over unfamiliar mountains laced with vineyards. I was lost, but at least it was in a beautiful place. And, probably without hotels.

Venga, he said, and I followed him to a little office inside the train station. As he began packing up his things, I studied him: With ash-blonde hair, a beard, and a stocky frame, the train conductor, whose name was Carmine, looked more like a lumberjack than the Italians I’d met in Rome. Perhaps his heartiness made me trust him when he suggested I stay with him and his family that night. The next day, he proposed, he would drive me to my relative’s house, about a 20-minute drive.

At this point in the retelling of the story for Julia, to whom I always repeat the advice “don’t talk to strangers,” I feel a slight compulsion to edit out my unquestioning response: Va bene. Okay.

But instead, I tell her the real version of what happened, which is: nothing. Or nothing bad — and everything good. Within a few minutes of getting in the train conductor’s car, we were a casa, where his wife, a robust woman with long, curly black hair welcomed me. Who knows what he told her in Italian about this young, American solo-traveling girl with a backpack almost as big as she was, but whatever it was generated immediate sympathy for me.

She made a big pot of spaghetti, and a couple of other adults joined us for dinner. They served red wine, which loosened me up to try out my Italian. They wanted to know all about me: where I was from in America, why I was in Italy, who my relatives were. They sent me to bed with a cup of chamomile tea, and I slept until morning. After a breakfast of a caffè latte and cookies, the train conductor drove me straight to Angelina, who was relieved to see me. I exchanged addresses with Carmine, and when I got back to America, we wrote each other a few times.

At this point in my re-telling, Julia is fast asleep, and I am transported enough in my memory to soon follow suit. But first, the moral of the story, told only to myself — a mantra that I experienced at least a few more times after my Italian journey: Let strangers be part of your story. Sometimes they are just the people you need to meet.

Kristine Crane is Associate Editor of The American and the author of the "L'Americana" column. She lives and writes in North Central Florida. She was formerly a Fulbright scholar and journalist in Rome, where she helped found "The American." She is originally from Iowa City.