February 22, 2024 | Rome, Italy

Robert Dahl

By |2018-03-21T18:18:24+01:00January 1st, 2005|Interviews|
Dahl has little good to say about exporting democracy.

obert Dahl is baffled. Democracy isn’t something you try on like a new suit, says the 89-year-old Sterling Professor Emeritus of political scientist at Yale. Dahl, who has written extensively on American democracy, taught at Yale when President George W. Bush and Sen. John F. Kerry were students there, and recalls reading the senior essay of 2000 vice presidential candidate Sen. Joseph Lieberman. Born in 1915 in rural Iowa, Dahl’s family moved to Alaska, not yet a state, in 1925. He paid $30 a course to attend the University of Washington and did graduate work at Yale. He interned in Washington, D.C at a time when the New Deal, not the War on Terror, was the political buzz. He fought in World War II before turning to teaching. He lectured in Rome recently, where Jessica Ricci chatted with him.

Is anti-Americanism a media invention or substantive?

I don’t think there has been a time in American history in which our international credibility and standing — our moral standing — has been as low as it has been. That is extremely difficult to recover [from]. While some very hardheaed people might argue that moral standing isn’t important, it is a huge asset. If people don’t trust you, don’t believe in your policies, they begin to feel that you can’t be trusted to carry out reasonable policies. That’s a huge loss in the international force. That appears to have happened quite seriously, especially with the Europeans, but not only with the Europeans.

Is America truly polarized?

Yes, but less about policy as such, or even the war. The polarization [is] between Democrats and Republicans, 40 percent committed Democrats, 40 percent committed Republicans; the polarization is over George Bush himself and the conduct of his presidency. Many deeply committed Republicans accept this picture of the world in black and white, in moral and good and bad, and good and evil. That’s part of their psychological perception.

The current administration talks about exporting democracy to Iraq. How do we know that Iraq can sustain democracy?

Paul Wolfowitz … was a younger member of my [Yale political science] department. [He’s] an intelligent man, I think he’s a thoughtful man, and [I don’t know] how he could believe that Iraq could be converted to a democratic order quickly and that we would be met by them. [People] appear really to believe that a transition would be simple, straightforward…. The understanding is so shallow…

It baffles me [this belief] that you can export democracy to countries that don’t have the basic support systems for democracy, that don’t have the rule of law, for example, that don’t have economies, that don’t have some of the basic freedoms of discussion that provide a structure. Political culture is what you grow up with, what you take for granted. You learn it early and you assume it.

I think that we have increased enormously the threat and likelihood of terrorism by our actions. Going into Iraq to stamp out terrorism? We’ve generated it. I can’t see an endpoint to it.

The separation between church and state seems to be narrowing in the United States. Do you see this trend?

We have to distinguish two things: one is whether the number of fundamentalist Christians is increasing, or if their influence is increasing. It’s the second. There’s not much evidence that they are increasing in numbers. But, their influence has increased and the Bush Administration of course has enormously facilitated that because they were open to [the fundamentalist Christians] as part of their base and helped them to mobilize. Not that they are a larger group, but their political influence is bigger.

If Thomas Jefferson were alive today, what do you think would be his strongest criticism of the current administration?

Making all the allowances that make Thomas Jefferson a product of his time… he would be frightened and appalled.

About the Author:

Jessica Ricci received her Master's degree in journalism from New York University. She wrote for several publications in New York, lived in Rome for three years, and now runs a jewelry business in Providence, Rhode Island.