November 30, 2023 | Rome, Italy

Knox and Davis

By |2018-03-21T18:46:16+01:00October 6th, 2011|Essays|
Amanda Knox: Despite her acquittal, opinions remain split.

ost likely we’ll never know what happened before Meredith Kerchner’s murder outside Perugia in 2007, and reactions to the conviction and vindication of Raffaele Sollecito and Amanda Knox have been difficult to parse out.

As an American who lives in Brooklyn, I thought Amanda Knox was innocent, while my wife, an Italian-American, also in Brooklyn, wasn’t so sure. But we were both relieved when she was released because the punitive quality of American justice makes us sympathetic to defendants.

My sense of the case may have been biased by how innocent and vulnerable she seemed, but the villainous way she was cast by the prosecution also reminded me of the story of my wife’s aunt, who was crowned town slut in Sorrento in the 1950’s and kept the honor until her death a couple of years ago.

My wife’s opinion, on the other hand, was certainly influenced by her frustration with the stereotypes of Italy and Italians she’s seen over and over in the American and British press.

The story of the American and Italian reactions to the case (according to The New York Times) has gone along somewhat the same lines. Many Americans view her as a chaste girl victimized by a corrupt Italian justice system. Many Italians view her as slutty, drug-crazed and the beneficiary of a typically condescending American intervention into Italian law.

As I followed the story in the American media, I could not help but think about the last legal case that captured our collective imagination: the failed appeals and execution of Troy Davis, an African American who was the victim of the worst qualities of American justice: racism, evident in the Savannah police department’s handling of the case; corruption, the police’s department scaring eyewitnesses into lying and inflexibility, several courts refusing to seriously reconsider the case despite the change of heart of almost all those eyewitnesses and lack of physical evidence.

The same Italian justice that some Italians deride as weak and American-influenced proved stellar in exactly the ways in which the American justice system failed so miserably.

Amanda Knox was given jail time (albeit already served) and fined for her racist slander of an African immigrant in Perugia. The appellate court efficiently and honorably allowed independent DNA experts to investigate and later testify about the case, and (as is typical, I gather, in Italy) showed the flexibility to reconsider a verdict.

Joy Behar, on the ABC Television talk show The View, complained about the guilty-until-proven innocent nature of the Italian courts (which are actually extremely liberal). But poor black American males can “prove” their innocence all they want but are still often found guilty.

So while Italians bemoan their American-influenced court system, and Americans scorn what they perceive to be a “Banana Republic” trial, I salute Italian justice, mourn American injustice, and am pleased that a pretty and vulnerable looking American girl, who may well be a murderess, is returning “safely” to Seattle.

About the Author:

Fiction Editor David Winner is a novelist ("The Cannibal of Guadalajara," "Tyler's Last") who has twice been nominated for the Pushcart Prize. He has published in "The Village Voice," "Fiction," "The Cortland Review and the "Kenyon Review." His story "My Lover's Moods" was made into a short film screened at the 2007 Cannes Film Festival.