December 7, 2023 | Rome, Italy


By |2018-03-21T18:30:35+01:00October 1st, 2005|Reviews|


Date: 2005

Director: Paul Haggis

Starring: Matt Dillon, Don Cheadle, Ryan Philippe, Brendan Fraser, Michael Peña


irector Paul Haggis’ Melting Pot jigsaw about bigotry, humiliation, and redemption is too obvious for its own good. In the ensemble tradition of L.A. magical realism (“Magnolia,” “Short Cuts”), Haggis links day in the life of two black street kids (Laranz Tate and Ludacris), a good black cop (Don Cheadle), a conflicted white cop (Matt Dillon), a black TV producer (Terrence Howard), a Latino locksmith (Michael Peña), an Iranian merchant (Shaun Taub), an ambitious DA (Brendan Fraser), and their family and colleagues.

Beneath violent impulses (and violence itself) is the notion that compassion can give peace a chance. Some characters fare better than others, with Haggis bluffing to extend his story. “I’m angry all the time and I don’t know why,” says Sandra Bullock, who plays the DA’s spoiled wife. “You think you know who you are, you have no idea,” racist cop Dillon (who’s very good) tells his disapproving young partner played by Ryan Philippe (who will later commit a stunning crime). Haggis handles these predicaments with slick empathy.

But he also adds hymnal choirs to impregnate moments you’re meant to understand “matter deeply,” an annoying in an ambitious film. He’s at best with the volatile: Howard’s face-off with police is deft; and with family: Peña makes the most of a brief bedroom scene with his young daughter. As noble as Haggis is, the snippet-acting narrative is too neat and the object lessons too honed. Ambiguity is surrendered to New Age singsong (not to mention LA snow). Yes, it’s beautiful to look at, but it never breaks a sweat. Won best movie Oscar.

About the Author:

A military brat, Marcia Yarrow was born in Hamburg, Germany but grew up in Germany, Spain, and Provo, Utah. She's been writing for the magazine since its creation in 2004.